San Diego's $10-an-Hour Downtown Parking Sparks Fierce Backlash as City Grapples with $258 Million Budget Crisis

Special event pricing near Petco Park raises charges by 700% since 2024, drawing criticism from businesses, fans, and even the Padres organization

SAN DIEGO — A controversial new parking pricing scheme that charges drivers $10 per hour during major events near Petco Park has ignited a firestorm of criticism from downtown businesses, workers, and fans who say the city has gone too far in its efforts to plug a massive budget deficit.

The special event pricing, which took effect September 1, represents a dramatic escalation in San Diego's parking fee increases. The $10 hourly rate is a 700% increase from the $1.25 rate that was in place just last year, and four times higher than the current standard rate of $2.50 per hour.

The surge pricing applies to all parking meters within a half-mile radius of Petco Park during events with 10,000 or more attendees, including San Diego Padres games and concerts. The special rates are in effect for six hours total — starting two hours before an event and continuing for four hours after it begins — meaning fans could pay up to $60 just to park on the street.

Business Community Pushes Back

The Gaslamp Quarter Association, representing more than 400 downtown businesses, sent a scathing letter to Mayor Todd Gloria in late August demanding the city delay or scrap the pricing plan.

"This plan fails to account for the very real and immediate consequences to downtown's workforce, residents and business community," the association wrote. "This surge pricing plan threatens the long-term economic viability of small businesses, jeopardizes employment across the restaurant and lodging industries, and ignores the real-world challenges of operating in downtown San Diego."

The backlash has extended beyond typical business complaints. Alexander Kale, manager at Water Grill in the Gaslamp Quarter, told local media that the restaurant has lost crew members who quit rather than pay half their daily wages for parking. "They're mostly taking home $110-$120 per day, so if you're going into half of that, it's not worth it," Kale said.

Even the San Diego Padres, whose home games trigger the surge pricing, expressed frustration with the city's approach. "The city made this decision without meaningful input from key stakeholders, including the Padres organization," a team spokesperson said in a statement.

Driving Force: Unprecedented Budget Crisis

The parking increases are part of San Diego's desperate attempt to address what officials describe as the worst budget crisis in decades. The city faces a projected $258 million general fund deficit for fiscal year 2026, with some estimates suggesting the shortfall could reach over $300 million.

The budget crisis stems largely from skyrocketing pension costs that now consume more than $533 million annually — the first time the city's pension payment has exceeded half a billion dollars. The pension system is only 75% funded, leaving taxpayers with $3.3 billion in unfunded liabilities.

"This year, San Diegans are paying $490 million for city pensions," according to analysis by the Reason Foundation. "Any salary or pension benefit increases for city workers would further drive up short- and long-term costs."

The city's pension troubles trace back to the reversal of voter-approved Proposition B in 2012, which would have replaced traditional pensions with 401(k)-style plans for new employees. After the reform was overturned by public worker unions through the courts, incorporating affected employees back into the legacy pension system cost the city $142 million and raised annual pension contributions by $48 million.

City finance officials project deficits will continue for years, with the Department of Finance estimating total deficits from 2026 to 2030 could reach $1.03 billion.

How Other Cities Handle Downtown Event Parking

San Diego's approach puts it at the high end of West Coast cities' event parking strategies, though the comparison is complicated by different pricing structures and policies.

Los Angeles keeps downtown meter rates relatively modest, with prices starting at $0.50 per hour and maxing out around $5 downtown, even during events. The city relies more heavily on privately operated lots that charge market rates.

Seattle uses a more gradual approach, with paid parking generally limited to Monday through Saturday and rates that vary by district but typically don't exceed $5-6 per hour even in high-demand areas. The city offers free parking on Sundays in most areas.

Portland recently updated its parking rates with what officials called a "phased expansion" approach. The city extended pay-to-park hours to 10 p.m. daily downtown but implemented a "5 after 5" rule allowing up to 5 hours of parking starting at 5 p.m. in most districts. Portland's standard downtown rates remain significantly lower than San Diego's surge pricing.

Legal Framework and Revenue Restrictions

San Diego's ability to raise parking revenues faces certain legal constraints. Under state and local law, parking meter revenues "must be reinvested to benefit parking and mobility-related needs within the meter zone where they were collected," according to city statements.

However, legal analysis suggests the city may have more flexibility than officials acknowledge. A 2019 memorandum by transportation advocacy group Circulate San Diego argued that after California voters approved Proposition 26 in 2010, parking meter revenues should not be considered "regulatory fees" with restricted uses.

"Consideration of Proposition 26 and recent case law reveals that parking meter revenues are charges that do not constitute fees or taxes within the meaning of the relevant law," the analysis concluded, suggesting the revenues "can therefore legally be spent for any government purpose."

The city estimates the special event pricing, combined with extended meter hours and other parking changes, will generate approximately $9.9 million annually.

Commercial Lot Response

Private parking operators near Petco Park have long charged significantly higher rates during events, with costs ranging from $25 to $75 according to business leaders quoted in city discussions. This price differential was cited by some officials as justification for the meter increases.

"The fees for parking in lots near Petco Park range from $25 to $75 for various events," said Phil Blair of Manpower staffing firm. "It is unreasonable to expect the city lot equivalent, its parking meters, to charge only $1.25 per hour."

However, the commercial lots offer all-day pricing for events, while the meter system charges by the hour with a six-hour maximum, potentially making street parking more expensive for some visitors.

Economic Analysis: Did the City Go Too Far?

A survey of local economists and business leaders published in the San Diego Union-Tribune found overwhelming opposition to the pricing increase, with most respondents saying the city had gone too far.

UC San Diego economist James Hamilton argued the steep surcharge "slams the brakes" on bringing people downtown to shop and eat. "The city should look at spending, not revenue, to address its budget problems," Hamilton said.

San Diego State University economist David Ely noted that "the intensity of the response signals that the sharp increase in parking prices likely went too far," and called for the city to "carefully assess the responses of workers, fans and business customers."

Even supporters of increased parking fees suggested the city's approach was flawed. UC San Diego's Caroline Freund argued for escalating rates rather than a flat increase: "$5 for the first hour, $7.50 for the second, $10 for the third, and so on."

Transportation Alternatives and Enforcement

The city has encouraged visitors to use public transportation to avoid the parking fees. During Padres games, three trolley lines provide service to Petco Park every 15 minutes, and several bus routes offer frequent service to downtown.

To enforce the new pricing, the San Diego Police Department has requested 14 new parking enforcement positions. The violation fine for expired meters is $55, leading some to calculate whether it's cheaper to risk a ticket than pay the full hourly rate.

Looking Ahead

With 17 special events scheduled for September alone, and the pricing plan potentially in effect for approximately 100 days per year, the economic impact on downtown businesses and workers will become clearer in the coming months.

Business leaders continue to call for reconsideration of the policy. "If the city is getting pushback from its coveted downtown business base it's better to revisit this approach and explore alternative ways to achieve revenue," said Gary London of London Moeder Advisors.

The controversy over parking pricing reflects broader challenges facing San Diego as it attempts to balance budget pressures with maintaining downtown's economic vitality. With pension costs projected to continue rising and revenue growth lagging, city officials may face even more difficult choices in the years ahead.

---

Sources

1. Molnar, Phillip. "Did San Diego go too far with $10-an-hour parking for downtown special events?" San Diego Union-Tribune, September 5, 2025. https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/2025/09/05/did-san-diego-go-too-far-with-10-an-hour-parking-for-downtown-special-events/
2. "As $258M deficit looms, San Diego sees untapped revenue in parking meters." KPBS Public Media, December 19, 2024. https://www.kpbs.org/news/economy/2024/12/17/as-258m-deficit-looms-san-diego-sees-untapped-revenue-in-parking-meters
3. Shaheen, Perla. "Gaslamp Quarter Association expresses concerns about $10 per hour parking during special events." ABC 10News, August 26, 2025. https://www.10news.com/news/gaslamp-quarter-association-expresses-concerns-about-10-per-hour-parking-during-special-events
4. "Parking meter rates jump to $10/hour for Padres games, Petco Park events." NBC 7 San Diego, September 1, 2025. https://www.nbcsandiego.com/news/local/parking-meter-rates-padres-game-petco-park-special-events/3881836/
5. "San Diego hit with $533 million pension payment, an unprecedented sum in a painful budget year." San Diego Union-Tribune, March 14, 2025. https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/2025/03/14/san-diego-hit-with-533-million-pension-payment-an-unprecedented-sum-in-a-painful-budget-year/
6. "San Diego's extreme pension costs are forcing difficult budget choices." Reason Foundation, February 17, 2025. https://reason.org/commentary/why-are-so-many-of-san-diegos-needs-going-unmet-extreme-pension-costs/
7. Aere, Jacob. "Downtown special event parking prices draw backlash from San Diego groups." KPBS Public Media, August 19, 2025. https://www.kpbs.org/news/quality-of-life/2025/08/19/downtown-special-event-parking-prices-draw-backlash-from-san-diego-groups
8. "New parking rates, hours reflect increased demand across city as Portland thrives." City of Portland, July 1, 2025. https://www.portland.gov/transportation/news/2025/7/1/news-release-new-parking-rates-hours-reflect-increased-demand-across
9. "Paid Parking Rates." City of Seattle Transportation Department. https://www.seattle.gov/transportation/projects-and-programs/programs/parking-program/paid-parking-information/street-parking-rates
10. "Find and Compare Parking in Los Angeles." SpotHero. https://spothero.com/city/los-angeles-parking
11. "Memorandum: Permissible Expenditures by Community Parking Districts." Circulate San Diego, 2019. https://www.circulatesd.org/memorandum_permissible_expenditures_by_community_parking_districts
12. "City Council Approves Comprehensive Update to Parking Regulations." Inside San Diego, June 11, 2025. https://www.insidesandiego.org/city-council-approves-comprehensive-update-parking-regulations
13. "San Diego's $300 million budget deficit may still be too 'rosy,' councilmember fears." KPBS Public Media, April 25, 2025. https://www.kpbs.org/news/local/2025/04/24/san-diegos-300-million-budget-deficit-may-still-be-too-rosy-councilmember-fears
14. Did San Diego go too far with $10-an-hour parking for downtown special events? – San Diego Union-Tribune